Subscribe for more SMT and Persona videos!
Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/crawling_nyarly
Consider donating on Ko-Fi: https://ko-fi.com/nyarly
Subscribe to my Twitch channel: https://www.twitch.tv/nyaarly
In this video I discuss the recently leaked trailers for Persona 3 Reload and Persona 5 Tactica. I give my thoughts and opinions on the new Persona 3 remake and the newest Persona 5 spinoff and what I think this means for Atlus’s future as well.
Intro by Lyric: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCN508DxgoQofsmst-d1BFDQ
#persona3remake #Atlus #persona3reload
35 Comments
Idk why people are acting as if the remake not having The Answer is just as likely as it not having FemC (R.I.P Phemsee), that is literally like a sequel, call it Persona 3 Eternal Answering lol and it has really important lore not only for the P3 characters but also general lore like personas being shadows which was established in The Answer.
Btw for the P3P "remaster" (more like a demaster of a demaster), it was most likely outsourced since the only thing that took work to do was:
add more options
make the game 60 FPS
horribly upscale the game with AI
i.e it was a very lazy remaster.
did you see etrian odyssey hd is on steam now?
Calling it now for P3Reload:
A remake of the base game only (no content from FES or Portable), not making Reload the actual definitive edition. AGAIN.
And as a bonus, Junpei's VA ( Vic Mignogna) not returning and script largely re-written "for today's sensibilities".
Completely new Persona 5 spinoff YAAWN
Persona 3 again Yippee!!!
Does this guy even like Atlus?
Persona 5 has been milked so much, but Atlus has a found a way to make it artificial and milk it even more.
i don’t like this bright saturated blue, the original more muted blue is better and fits in with a “dark” theme of the game. also this ux especially during the battle is… something. but since the game doesn’t have a date of release i hope they’ll change it.
i’m so sad they kept this old ass grinding random generated floors that are so annoying to explore, they look so wide and empty 💀
I'll bet you anything the P3 Remake won't have The Answer or FemC. Don't get your hope up. Atlus WILL disappoint us
The Persona 3 Reload looks exactly like what I wanted from a rerelease and rumors from a while ago there's no female MC so that why they did the rerelease of P3P. Yeah im not sure if it will have the Answer in it or not from FES but it probably could be DLC knowing Sega/Atlus these days. For Persona 5 Tactica I hope people don't buy it I'm ready for 5 to die like 4 which they milked to death. If they do another remake I'm hoping, it's Persona 2 but we'll likely end up getting Persona 4 Remake.🥵
I think it was legit not approved, cause job postings were up for social media related jobs the day after the leak happened.
This is modern Atlus aka Sega we're talking about here of course FeMC and the Answer are going to be DLC because money also it will likely have a new character added that will change the fate of the protagonist if you complete their storyline but I see no one talking about this thing that happens in every Atlus remaster/remake also despite all the demand for it there are already people bitching it looks like P5 and not like P3 saying they ruined it by not haveing the revolver menu of the original and my reaction to that is realy? You people screamed and yelled for years for a version of P3 that had P5 level graphics and now that you got it it looks too much like P5 god people can never be pleased -_-
Calling it now: The Answer will be Day 1 DLC and be a lot shorter
I'm not worried about them withholding FeMC just because of the P3P port. That port was part of a shotgun release that put "all 3" modern Persona games on all platforms. That to me smells mostly of Microsoft marketing dollars, further reinforced by these new trailers also being made for the XBox presentation. The P3P port is a placeholder, there to be a "we got all of them out" statement more than anything. Still, holding back confirmation on the main narrative content is troubling, since it wouldn't have taken much for them to put a second of footage into the trailer to confirm either/both of those. Could be a way to stretch out the hype by announcing it later, could be a red flag.
Glad you clarified point on need for difinitive edition, but saying FES just lacked femc is understatement. Femc was cool, but direct commands for party members was the biggest jump for me with the P3P version. Love the control, but despise the graphic novel format of P3P.
Unpopular opinion I’m not a fan of FEMc I prefer Male MC.
I think the reason for P3P being remastered was because it it weren't; A, people would get fucking mad and B, People would get suspicious. That's probably why P3P was a lazy release
Is it worth playing the port of persona 3 portable before the remake comes out? I bought it when it came out but never got to it.
It makes sense to port portable and then not include kotone. Is it shitty? Yes. But it also saves on development time for fully modeling everything for her, and helped "conceal" the remake until now. Also now that we have the context of the remake, it also explains why portable HD was so low effort. Them cutting her means portable will still be relevant, and an option for those who want to play her. Its not ideal, but it makes sense from Atlus's business perspective. Low effort for maximum potential profit.
That said, the seeming lack of the answer is what hurts me. Unlike Kotone and portable HD, there is no legal way to play FES, and it's fairly dated and hard to play the answer compared to even just portable. They could've taken the time to rebalance it and help some pacing issues, and i think reload couldve been the definitive remake of FES.
But those are ultimately minor gripes for me. Im hella excited for this game, and cant wait for it. P3fes is my second favorite game of all time, and i already own portable on vita and switch, so i can do kotone runs whenever i want to.
It would be criminal for Atlus to finally hear the fans out on remaking Persona 3, only to exclude EVERYTHING they wanted the remake to be. A definitive version. To have portable's FeMC, controllable party members, FES multiple equipable weapons, the answer, skill selection during fusion, and a version of the answer that switched minato out for minako for the hell of there being a FeMC's answer. If we get P3Reload and it's base P3 with way better graphics and nothing else. The fans will ACTUALLY march on Atlus' main HQ like Americans did the white house.
Persona fans when they get what they want 😡😡😡
it's gg boyos, no p6 for quite some time
Of course P6 is being worked on. This happened with the wait between P4 and P5, too, where there seemed to be an endless amount of collabs and spin-offs with P4 (and even a portable release of P3, and the new IP Catherine) while P5 was being worked on. It's just how Atlus operates. But games have gotten more complicated and they take way more time to make now, so given Atlus's already long development cycle even in the 2010s, it does not surprise me that it's taking this long at all, or that there are this many spin-offs of P5. But at the very least, Persona games seem to always release finished, spin-offs included.
how many p5 spinoffs are we going to get? It’s honestly getting annoying.
Also yay P3 remake
If they added all the special features in each version of persona 3 i think it could be satisfying to play as u can play the answer in a new graphics and FEMC in a 3d model rather than a visual novel style i think would be an amazing thing though drawbacks is probably the storage capacity would increase
at least we'll be able to change party skills so junpei can have a pierce skill for the entire game
I wish we can get an smt 1 & 2 remake and persona 1 & 2 remake but that's asking too much from Atlus its such a shame
I'm really unsure about why people think The Answer won't be in there? Was there something in the trailer that implied it would be absent?
femc not being in there is a reasonable conclusion, since the trailer should show off the second mc (still huffing copium that we'll get her anyway) but any footage of The Answer would be 100% an endgame spoiler so like why would it be in the trailer?
All these remakes but I want a Giten Megami Tensei remake.
As a long time Persona and Atlas fan this didn't surprise me. They do everything for that quick extra buck (can't blame them though) and fans either accept it or not lol. I'm still loving P3 remake for the sheer fact it's still my top Persona title aside from 5.
I disliked your video for your opinion. Have a good day sir
If you think about it, this is basicly persona 3 defenetive version, you can see in the trailer that you can control Yukari, which is sonething form portable, and you also have the over world, which from FES, I get you all want the female route, but I don't really care about that, plus it's not canon, so maybe Atlus is just doing a "canon" route remake, but since I really don't care about the female route, I wouldn’t mind if it was added, but overall, I feel like persona 3 reload is basicly the defenetive version
I'm not going to hold my breath, but there's always a chance that the female protagonist and/or The Answer will be revealed in a future trailer. That would be a good marketing strategy that keeps the hype going.
Let's be honest with ourselves. FemMC and The Answer will not be in the remake
The Yukari leak looks nothing even similar to P5X, idk how you guys even see that as a similarity? If you don't believe it at that time, you have to read what sonic fans thought about it, because of them, I believe the leak is real 100%, and now look where we are😌
Persona 3 Holds up terribly bro. I love it so much but the gameplay needs a remake. You’re lying you’re ass off with nostalgia glasses if you think otherwise. Persona 3 is still great just a little outdated and that’s okay.